How in the world do they make M and M ice cream that doesn't wind up puce colored? Because it's homemade ice cream, it always winds up rock hard. So, you've got to either let the ice cream sit and thaw on the counter or nuke it a bit on defrost before you can scoop it. If you don't you'll end up with a broken spoon or ice cream container. Not that I've learned from experience or anything.
When you let ice cream with M and M's sit out, the color melts off the candies. And they bleed. Leaving you with a hot mess of ice cream.
Not unlike our friend here.
It's not a pretty sight.
Luckily, the ice cream was tasty! I made it with unsweetened almond milk. Not cause I'm against milk or anything. I love milk. Dairy does not love me. I can only consume a small amount and I choose to eat that in cheese. (Cheese makes the world go round! Anyone else ever sing that song?) I can make my own non dairy ice cream, but it's a lot harder to make my own non dairy blue cheese.
I think this tastes just like an oatmeal cookie in ice cream form. I'd love to ramp this up next time by adding oatmeal cookie dough pieces too it. I'd also leave the M and M's out to avoid the disgusting color swirls.
Oatmeal Cookie Ice Cream from Chocolate Covered Katie
2 2/3 c milk of choice, or creamer
1/3 c oat flour ( grind rolled oats to powder in a food processor. Measure after blending.)
1/2 t salt
1/4 t baking soda (for flavor; can be omitted)
1/2 t cinnamon
1/3 c raisins (or other add in just beware that your M and M's will bleed)
1/2 c brown sugar
3 T sugar
2 T “butter” (Dairy or non dairy)
1 t vanilla
Combine all ingredients except vanilla (Do include raisins, but not M & Ms or they will melt), Nuke 3 1/2 min, stir, and nuke another 2 min. Add vanilla. Chill in fridge til cold again (about 4 hrs). Pour into ice cream maker and churn per manufacture instructions. Transfer to an airtight container. (Fold in M and M's at this point if using.) Freeze for about an hour. If you choose to freeze this longer than an hour, it will be very hard and you will need to let it defrost for a bit before servin.